Bird islands: On India’s bustard conservation programme
What does this development mean for UPSC preparation?
Two captive-bred Great Indian Bustards were released into the wild at Desert National Park, Jaisalmer, marking progress in the conservation breeding programme.
UPSC CSE Context
Why in News
Two captive-bred Great Indian Bustards were released into the wild at Desert National Park, Jaisalmer, marking progress in the conservation breeding programme.
Syllabus Connection
Environment and Ecology: Conservation, biodiversity, species protection, and related policies.
Exam Relevance
High relevance for UPSC CSE due to the intersection of conservation, renewable energy, and judicial interventions; useful for both Prelims and Mains.
Core Issue
India's conservation approach is species-centric and symbolic, neglecting landscape-level habitat protection.
Key Development
Release of captive-bred Great Indian Bustards highlights success but also exposes the limitations of isolated conservation efforts.
Stakeholders
- Government of India
- Rajasthan Government
- Renewable energy companies
- Local communities
- Conservationists
Static Knowledge
High-Value Background
- The Great Indian Bustard is critically endangered, with a population of around 120 individuals, primarily in Rajasthan.
- The species faces threats from habitat loss due to agricultural expansion, power lines, and historical hunting.
Exam Linkage
- Useful for questions on biodiversity conservation, human-wildlife conflict, and environmental governance.
Concepts in Context
- Captive breeding and reintroduction are ex-situ conservation strategies.
- Landscape-level conservation focuses on preserving entire ecosystems rather than single species.
Institutions and Mechanisms
- Desert National Park, Jaisalmer, is a key protected area for the Great Indian Bustard.
- The Supreme Court of India has intervened to mandate undergrounding power lines in critical habitats.
Dynamic Analysis
Environment and Ecology
- Captive breeding success does not address the primary threats of habitat loss and power line collisions in the wild.
- Focus on charismatic species like bustards and tigers diverts attention from declining common bird populations.
- Grassland ecosystems, often undervalued as wastelands, require protection beyond species-specific measures.
Governance
- Conservation policies are driven by symbolism and bureaucratic events rather than ecological science.
- The Supreme Court's modified order reflects the challenge of balancing renewable energy goals with species protection.
- Lack of integrated land-use planning leads to fragmented habitats and increased human-wildlife conflict.
Economy
- Undergrounding power lines imposes high costs on renewable energy projects, affecting their viability.
- Eco-tourism and marketing of species like the Godawan can provide economic incentives for conservation.
- Compensation mechanisms for farmers affected by wildlife are inadequate, leading to resentment.
Society
- Conflict arises when conservation areas restrict traditional livelihoods without providing alternatives.
Prelims Takeaways
- Great Indian Bustard is listed as Critically Endangered on the IUCN Red List.
- Desert National Park is located in Jaisalmer, Rajasthan.
Mains Value Addition
Arguments
- Species-centric conservation fails to address ecosystem-level threats and may lead to maladaptive outcomes.
- Judicial interventions in conservation must balance ecological needs with developmental imperatives.
- Community participation is essential for sustainable conservation, requiring economic incentives and conflict mitigation.
Examples
- The Great Indian Bustard conservation programme, with 97 birds in captivity and 57 captive-bred, illustrates ex-situ efforts.
- The Supreme Court's 2021 order on undergrounding power lines in bustard habitats highlights legal-environmental conflicts.
Data Points
- Great Indian Bustard population: around 120 individuals.
- 1,256 bird species (11.5% of world's total) are classified as threatened.
Counterpoints
- Captive breeding may not ensure survival in the wild if threats remain unmitigated.
- Undergrounding power lines could hinder renewable energy expansion, affecting climate goals.
- Focus on flagship species may neglect less charismatic but ecologically important species.
Way Forward
- Adopt landscape-level conservation planning that integrates protected areas with surrounding land uses.
- Promote community-based conservation through incentives, alternative livelihoods, and participatory governance.
- Develop technological solutions like bird diverters and undergrounding in critical habitats to reduce power line collisions.
- Strengthen environmental impact assessments to account for biodiversity in infrastructure projects.
- Increase funding for research and monitoring of lesser-known threatened species and their habitats.